Russia Today
Volume 76, Number 1 (Spring 2009)

Recommended Reading

South Africa: The Second Decade
(Conference Proceedings)
Vol. 74 No. 1 (Spring 2007)

China in Transition
(Conference Proceedings)
Vol. 73 No. 2 (Summer 2006)

Their America: The U.S. in the Eyes of the Rest of the World
(Conference Proceedings)

Vol. 72 No. 4 (Winter 2005)

Prospects for Democracy
Vol. 66 No. 3 (Fall 1999)

You may also be interested in the other issues in our Transitions/East Central Europe series.


Editor's Introduction

In keeping with our policy to publish recurring issues on places in the world undergoing or recently having undergone marked changes (see our issues on China [Volume 73:1, Spring 2006] and South Africa [Volume 72:3, Fall 2005]), this issue looks at current aspects of the Russian state and society during a period of many deep, systemic changes.

Our readers should be aware that we began putting this issue together well before the Russian election that took place on March 2, 2008, in the hope of publishing an assessment by knowledgeable specialists of the consequences of that election. Due to various unforeseen editorial decisions and vicissitudes, the issue is appearing one year after that election and during an economic crisis that is much worse than when these articles were written. Even so, some of our authors do discuss some the problems created by falling oil prices, which began many months ago and severely impacted the Russian economy that prospered only as long as those prices remained high.

It is, as our readers surely know, impossible for a quarterly to be up to date when it tackles current events. There is simply too much delay time between inviting authors to write and the actual publication of their papers. Nevertheless, we will continue to examine these kinds of issues in the belief that reflective pieces on quickly changing global matters can increase our understanding of what is going on and what is likely to happen.

I think that is true of the current issue. While the economic crisis dominates the headlines, the issue itself traces the trajectories of a host of other concerns, social and political, in the years since the transition from the Yeltsin era to the Putin and then Medvedev era. It highlights especially the stamp Putin has put on contemporary Russia, and it is these discussions that can help us better understand the new Russia that will be affected by this crisis.

—Arien Mack

Table of Contents

 

Click author name for bio. Click title to order article or issue online.

 

Anders Åslund Why Market Reform Succeeded and Democracy Failed in Russia

Postcommunist transformation has led to quite different results. The starkest example is Russia, which has become a thriving market economy with an average real growth of 7 percent a year for a decade from 1999 to 2008, but Freedom House (2008) ranks it as a "not free" or authoritarian state. In this article, I define what I mean by saying that Russia is a market economy but not democratic. To clarify how this happened, I shall compare democracy to policymaking with regard to a market economy in the years after the collapse of the Soviet Union, which I consider to have undergone a revolution. Finally, I shall consider the contradiction that has arisen between an increasingly authoritarian state and an ever wealthier market economy. My argument is that this contradiction is too great to last for long.

Timothy Frye, Andrei Yakovlev and Yevgeny Yasin The “Other” Russian Economy: How Everyday Firms View the Rules the Game in Russia

We report results from two original surveys of 500 firms conducted in 2000 and 2007 in eight regions in Russia that explore the business environment for manufacturing and service sector firms. We find that the formal and informal rules of the game for everyday firms in Russia have changed dramatically in the Putin years. Most importantly, while the informal and formal rules of the game in 2000 were quite similar for firms that were investing and those that were not, in 2007 regional governments had come to favor the former through a variety of informal and formal means. This shift in the rules of the game in favor of firms that invest suggests that a core group of firms in the regions under study have managed to cooperate with the regional government to temper the weak institutional environment in Russia, but also that the playing field for businesses in Russia is not level.

Marshall Goldman Russia: A Petrostate in a Time of Worldwide Economic Recession and Political Turmoil

As a mono-energy-economy, Russia’s fortunes are closely linked to the price of energy. That same link explains why when energy prices hit record highs, there was such strong public support for Vladimir Putin. But when energy prices plummeted in late 2008, Russia found itself with an economic downturn which brought with it, factory closings, worker layoffs and political grumbling. Because of Russia’s inexperience with economic upheaval, Russia is likely to go through greater turmoil and political uncertainty if not unrest, than more traditional market economies which over the years have had to learn how to deal with economic cycles of this sort.

Sergei Alex Oushakine “Stop the Invasion!”: Money, Patriotism, and Conspiracy in Russia

Based on a set of interviews and materials collected in Barnaul (Siberia) in 2001-2005, this article explores discursive mechanisms through which new social realities and new social identities are imagined, negotiated, and internalized in postsocialist Russia. By analyzing popular conspiracy narratives about universal lie, corruption, and manipulation, the article draws attention to the increasing prominence of images and ideas of an enclosed national community that are used to counterbalance the perceived exposure to foreign values and capital after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Fyodor Lukyanov Putin’s Russia: The Quest for a New Place

The economic crisis has created a basically new situation. Russia should reduce its geopolitical ambitions, which have emerged in the last few years, as well as its national budget. The illusions of might, based on the possession of expensive commodities that everyone needs, are fading. There is no doubt that in a couple of years the demand for energy resources will grow again. But until then, Russia will have to go through another period of difficulties, whose outcome is not clear. Depending on its outcome, Putin's epoch will be viewed either as a time of lost opportunities, or as the eve of a real revival of Russia as a modern great power.

Dale R. Herspring Vladimir Putin: His Continuing Legacy

When Putin became president at the beginning of the 21st century, Russia was in shambles. Putin saw his task to be two fold. First, to recreate the Russian state – that had been seriously weakened by Boris Yeltsin. Second, he set out to reestablish Russia as an important international actor. His approach to dealing with those two tasks was heavily influenced by his approach to dealing with political problems. He is determined, but non ideological. He believes that Russia is unique and that only "Russian" solutions will resolve the country’s problems. Most of all, Putin sees himself as a "problem solver," something that comes from his years in the KGB. And while much remains to be done, he did a lot to solve Russia’s problems. The power of the state has been restored, and Russia is taken far more seriously on the international stage than it was in 2000. What is amazing, given all of the criticism he has received in the West for his "undemocratic" actions, his standings in the polls for the eight years he was in office remained above 70%, something a Western politician can only dream of.

Jessica Allina-Pisano Property: What Is It Good For?

 

Andrei Kortunov Russian Higher Education

The paper gives an overview of the Russian higher education history, outlines its current state, the challenges and opportunities for its modernization in the nearest future. A special emphasis is made on the role of international cooperation in the higher education development and prospects for Russia’s integration into the global educational space. Andrei Kortunov is President of the Moscow based New Eurasia Foundation. He has managed a number of education-focused programs in Russia, working closely with governmental agencies, higher education institutions, international consultancies and foreign foundations.

Tomila Lankina Regional Developments in Russia: Territorial Fragmentation in a Consolidating Authoritarian State

The article surveys Russia’s regional and centre-periphery developments and their wider implications for the country’s political, economic, and territorial future. In particular, it discusses President Putin’s federalism and local government interventions and takes stock of the outcome of these and other relevant federal initiatives. The paper also discusses the broader implications of authoritarian state-building for the country’s social, economic, and territorial cohesion. Globalization-related external influences on regional economies and politics are also discussed and the significance of the hitherto largely neglected variable of geography in shaping the nature and intensity of these influences is highlighted. Using examples from China and India, the paper shows how globalization may have highly uneven economic and political regional impacts in territorially large countries. The paper suggests that in Russia, external influences from regional political and economic players such as the EU, other Western donors, or multinational corporations may impinge upon authoritarian tendencies however they are only bound to increase regional socio-economic and political divergence given their spatially uneven nature.

Alena Ledeneva From Russia with Blat: Can Informal Networks Help Modernize Russia?

Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Moscow has become a global city with a vibrant urban and cultural life-one of the most expensive capitals in the world with famous clubs and restaurants, as well as one of the most popular destinations for city workers and diplomats. Has corruption been instrumental in Moscow's development? The answer is complicated and in many ways a matter of definitions. It depends on whether one considers informal practices-inherited from Soviet times as well as new ones-as corrupt and how one conceptualizes corruption. I will illustrate some of these complications for the case of the Soviet practice of blat, explain its "monetization" and its evolving relationship with corruption in the post-Soviet transition, and analyze the role of informal networks in present-day Russia.

Nikolay Mitrokhin The Russian Orthodox Church in Contemporary Russia: Structural Problems and Contradictory Relations with the Government, 2000-2008

The Russian Orthodox Church, the biggest centralized religious institution in the post-Soviet space, has been going through major changes in the 2000s. These are connected to qualitative changes in the composition of believers and clergy as well as legal registration of rights on church property obtained from the government in the 1990s. This has led to substantial changes in internal policies, particularly a sharp decrease in the influence of fundamentalists, which had been rising over the previous decade. Moreover, the years of Putin's rule were years of failure in the church's relations with the government, which consistently denied the ROC's most important requests. In this paper we will examine the principal social developments that have been taking place within the Church in the first years of the twenty-first century.

Alexei V. Malashenko Islam in Russia

According to the 2002 census, the Muslim population of Russia was 14.5 million people. During the past decade, the idea of a Muslim demographic "threat" has spread, discussed most often by politicians with nationalist views, along with journalists and some writers. Islam remains a factor that regulates relations in society. The current revival of Islam is contradictory and diverse in terms of its consequences. Its main result is that we are dealing with a new Islam and new Muslims.

Dina Khapaeva Historical Memory in Post-Soviet Gothic Society

The collective historical amnesia that reigns in contemporary Russia demands an explanation. In the first part of my article I will analyze the mechanisms that suppress historical memory. I will focus my attention on two historical representations of critical relevance for this matter. First, I will discuss the Western-oriented ideology of the post-Soviet intelligentsia. Second, I will analyze the functioning of the myth of the "Great Patriotic War." In the second part of my paper I will address the influence of historical amnesia on contemporary Russian society. Deep distortions in moral judgments and social relations resulting from suppressed memory will be studied through an analysis of contemporary Russian fiction, especially fantasy. Finally, I will consider Russian Gothic society, which originates in historical amnesia.

The New School The New School Divisions Milano The New School for Management and Urban Policy The New School for General Studies The New School for Social Research Milano The New School for Management and Urban Policy Parsons The New School for Design Eugene Lang College The New School for Liberal Arts Mannes College The New School for Music The New School for Drama The New School for Jazz and Contemporary Music Mannes College The New School for Music
Copyright © 2008 Social Research